A US returns process EU brands can run profitably starts with two changes to the home-market playbook. The return rate in your model should be higher than European habits suggest, and the return policy becomes a business choice, since US law sets no general right to return an online purchase. Everything else in a reverse logistics plan follows from those two facts.
This is the fifth item on the Operations & Logistics list in our EU to US Expansion Checklist: build a returns process and reverse logistics plan before launch. Our guide puts the timing plainly, which is before the first returns spike and not after it. This post explains why US rates run higher and what the plan needs to cover.
How should a brand plan for US return rates before launch?
Model the return rate at the US online benchmark, then adjust it for your category and test it with real orders. The National Retail Federation and Happy Returns (opens in new tab) estimated in October 2025 that retailers would see 15.8% of annual sales returned in 2025, down from 16.9% the year before. The same report put online returns at 19.3% of online sales, and it said retailers expect 17% of holiday sales to come back.
Treat those figures as a starting range for a US returns process EU brands can stress-test. Your own rate will vary by category, price point, and how well your product pages set expectations. Our post on a six-month US market test shows how to gather real return data before you scale, and our post on a 12-month US P&L shows where returns belong in the model.
Why do US return rates run higher than many EU brands expect?
Two factors push in the same direction: who pays, and what shoppers have learned to do. In the EU, a Your Europe (opens in new tab) guide says that for a return within the 14-day withdrawal period, the consumer pays postage and packaging unless the seller offers to pay or failed to disclose the costs. In the US, the norm runs the other way. NRF found that 82% of consumers call free returns a major purchase consideration, up from 76%.
Behavior differs too. NRF reports that about two-thirds of consumers admit to at least one costly returns behavior, such as wardrobing or bracketing, and that consumers aged 18 to 30 averaged 7.7 online returns in the past 12 months. A 2022 survey of 2,600 online fashion shoppers by Cycleon, reported in SupplyChainBrain (opens in new tab), found 34% of US shoppers frequently return multiple purchases to keep one, against 20% of Europeans. It also found 28% of US shoppers admitted returning worn items, against 16% in Europe.
The headline gap is large. A Practical Ecommerce summary (opens in new tab) of Statista data says EU customers returned around 7% of ecommerce revenue in 2024, with sharp variation by country. Compare that with NRF's 19.3% for US online sales, but treat the comparison with care. The two figures come from different studies and methods, the Cycleon survey covers fashion only and is four years old, and categories vary widely within both regions.
What does US law require, and what is left to your policy?
Far less than the EU does. The EU's 14-day right of withdrawal applies to most online purchases without a stated reason. Federal US law has no equivalent for ecommerce. A ClaimLane guide (opens in new tab) says the FTC's cooling-off rule covers door-to-door and off-premises sales over $25 and not ecommerce, so online returns rely on the seller's policy plus state rules.
State rules still matter. The California Attorney General (opens in new tab) says California law does not require stores to give refunds generally, and a store that posts a clear limited or no-refund policy does not have to. A store that fails to post a required policy can owe a full refund within 30 days with proof of purchase, under Civil Code section 1723. The page lists exceptions for perishable, final-sale, used, and custom goods.
The lesson for an EU brand is to write down a US policy deliberately, since a US returns process EU brands launch with should state its own terms. Do not carry over the EU withdrawal terms by accident, and do not leave the US storefront without a clear policy. ClaimLane warns against an accidental hybrid, such as a US-style window on an EU storefront with no withdrawal-right disclosure, so keep the two markets' terms separate and ask counsel to review both. Our post on US product page localization covers where the policy belongs on the page.
What must a US returns process EU brands run include?
It needs to cover six decisions. The table lists them with the question each one answers.
| Decision | Question to answer before launch |
|---|---|
| Policy | What window, who pays for the label, and which items are final sale |
| Return location | Where do returns go, and does any return cross the border |
| Return method | Which drop-off and pickup options will customers expect |
| Disposition | Which returns are restocked, resold, refurbished, or written off |
| Refund speed | When does the refund go out, and when is an exchange offered first |
| Controls | How you spot repeat claimants, empty boxes, and false claims |
Each one needs an owner and a written rule, so your 3PL and your customer service team apply the same answer.
Where should US returns go, and should they cross the border?
To a US address, in most cases, for any US returns process EU brands run well. Returns that travel back to Europe add transit time, freight, and customs handling, and they delay the refund decision. ShopAppy's returnless refund guide (opens in new tab) notes that bulky, low-value items and cross-border returns shift the answer on whether a return is worth processing.
If goods do go back to Europe, duty may be recoverable. A ClaimLane guide on duty drawback (opens in new tab) says rejected merchandise drawback can recover up to 99% of duties paid on goods that customers return or reject and that are then exported, with claims filed within 5 years of import and 3 years of export. That is a vendor summary, so confirm eligibility with a licensed customs broker before you plan around it. Our post on local fulfillment vs cross-border shipping from Europe covers how your fulfillment model changes the returns flow.
How should customers send returns back?
Offer the options US shoppers use most. A DHL survey (opens in new tab) from late 2025 and early 2026 found that 43% of US shoppers prefer to return through a parcel shop, 39% from home, and 18% via a parcel locker. Europe looked similar for parcel shops at 42%, and it leaned further toward lockers at 33%. Cycleon's 2022 survey found 33% of US shoppers would drop a return at the local post office, against 46% of Europeans.
For your US returns process EU brands need a prepaid label with at least a home pickup and a drop-off option, and a return portal that works on a phone. NRF found that 76% of consumers prefer return options with an instant refund or exchange, and that 71% are less likely to shop with a retailer again after a bad returns experience. Speed and ease are part of the product.
When does a returnless refund make sense?
When the cost of processing the return exceeds what you can recover from the item. ShopAppy frames it as expected recovered value minus processing cost, and it gives an illustrative cost of about $12 to $38 for a routine small-parcel return. Its illustrative matrix suggests returnless by default under $20, a case-by-case call between $20 and $50, and mostly returns above that. The same article says to model your own numbers, since recovery rates vary far more than shipping costs do.
The risks are real. NRF reports that 9% of returns are fraudulent, and it lists overstated quantities, empty boxes, and decoy returns among the fast-growing types. ShopAppy suggests per-account caps, velocity rules, photo evidence for damage claims, and random sampling of physical returns. It also warns that fraud review can cost more than the fraud it prevents, and that publishing your threshold invites claims clustered just below it.
Some goods should never go returnless, including regulated, age-restricted, serialized, or recalled items. Our post on FDA and FTC requirements for EU brands covers which categories carry extra rules.
How do you build a US returns process EU brands can trust?
Work through five steps, and write each decision down.
Step 1: Set the return rate and the cost per return in your model
Start with the NRF benchmarks, adjust for your category, and add the cost to process a return. Include the label, handling, and the value you do not recover. Flow the numbers into your unit economics.
Step 2: Write your US return policy
Choose the window, the label rule, the refund timing, and the final-sale items. Check state disclosure rules with counsel, and keep the US terms separate from your EU withdrawal terms.
Step 3: Choose the return location and method
Set a US return address with your 3PL. Offer at least a home pickup and a drop-off option, and decide how you handle any return that must go back to Europe.
Step 4: Define disposition and returnless rules
Decide what happens to each returned unit, and set returnless thresholds by item value and recovery. Add per-account caps and a sampling rule for physical returns.
Step 5: Plan capacity for the spike
NRF says retailers plan to rely more on third-party logistics, seasonal staff, and longer return windows during the holidays. Agree on peak capacity with your 3PL before your first holiday, and review return reasons monthly. Our post on US delivery norms for EU brands covers how the service targets for return requests fit into the same plan.
Frequently asked questions
How should a brand plan for US return rates before launch?
Model the US online benchmark and adjust for your category. NRF estimated 15.8% of US sales and 19.3% of online sales would be returned in 2025. Test the assumption with early orders, and review it monthly. A US returns process EU brands can afford starts with a realistic rate.
Do US customers have a legal right to return online purchases?
Not under a general federal rule. Online returns depend on the seller's policy and on state rules, such as California's requirement to post a policy or allow returns within 30 days. Ask counsel to review your policy for each state you sell into.
Should I send US returns back to Europe?
Usually not. A US returns process EU brands run from a US address avoids the transit time, freight, and customs steps that cross-border returns add. If some do go back, ask a customs broker whether duty drawback can recover the duties, since the claim deadlines are strict.
What is a returnless refund, and when does it make sense?
It refunds the customer without requiring the item back. It makes sense when processing the return costs more than the item can recover, so it suits low-value goods. Set caps and checks to limit abuse, and exclude regulated or age-restricted goods.
What should you do next?
Download the EU to US Expansion Checklist (opens in new tab) and work through the Operations & Logistics list, including the returns item. Then read the fulfillment section of the EU to US Expansion Guide to plan your US returns process EU brands can rely on.
This post is general information and does not replace legal or customs advice. Return rules and customs treatment vary by state and product, so have counsel review your policy and a licensed customs broker confirm any drawback plan.


