Skip to main content

Sales Tax Nexus Isn't Just a Bigger VAT

Izba
November 23, 2026
10 min read
Share:

Sales tax nexus vs VAT is the difference between one harmonised EU system and a separate obligation in each US state. In the EU, one registration can cover distance sales to consumers in many Member States. In the US, a brand can owe tax collection in a state because its inventory sits there, or because its sales into that state pass a threshold, and each state writes its own rules.

This is the first item on the Legal & Tax list in our EU to US Expansion Checklist: map your sales tax nexus exposure before placing US inventory. Our guide says the US has no single tax authority like the VAT system you know. This post explains the sales tax nexus vs VAT gap, what triggers nexus, and how to map your exposure before you move stock.

How is US sales tax nexus different from VAT?

Nexus is a connection between a seller and a state that gives the state the right to require tax collection. VAT works as a shared framework applied across a bloc, while a US sales tax nexus vs VAT comparison shows 45 separate state systems, plus local rules on top. The table sets the two side by side.

Point EU VAT US sales tax
Who sets the rules A common EU framework, applied through each Member State's national law Each state sets its own rules, and counties and cities can add local taxes
Where tax is collected At each stage of the supply chain Only at the final sale
Recovering tax you paid Businesses can credit the VAT they pay on purchases No input tax credit, though buyers purchasing goods for resale use resale exemption certificates
Registration One OSS registration in a single Member State can cover distance sales across the EU A separate registration in each state where you have nexus
What triggers it An EU-wide distance sales threshold of EUR 10,000 a year Physical presence, such as inventory, or sales above a state's threshold
Rates A few national rates per country Rates that vary by state and locality

The scale is different too. The Tax Foundation (opens in new tab) reports that 45 states levy a state sales tax, 38 states allow local sales taxes, and the population-weighted average combined rate is 7.53%. Five states have no statewide sales tax: Alaska, Delaware, Montana, New Hampshire, and Oregon. Avalara (opens in new tab) counts more than 12,000 US sales and use tax jurisdictions.

The EU side is worth restating, since it explains why the US feels different. The Commission's One Stop Shop page (opens in new tab) says a business using an OSS scheme registers in one Member State, the Member State of identification, and submits OSS returns there. Those returns are additional to the VAT return a business files under its own domestic obligations. The US has no equivalent single portal.

What creates sales tax nexus in a US state?

Two things do: physical presence and economic activity. Physical presence covers an office, an employee, a warehouse, or inventory stored in the state. Economic nexus covers a seller with no physical footprint whose sales into a state pass that state's threshold.

The economic test dates from 2018. In South Dakota v. Wayfair (opens in new tab), the Supreme Court let states require sellers to register and collect once sales exceed an economic nexus threshold. TaxJar (opens in new tab) says the rule applies to a seller "no matter where they are located," so an EU brand shipping from Europe can reach a threshold.

Thresholds differ by state. Avalara's economic nexus guide (opens in new tab) lists dollar thresholds of $100,000, $250,000, and $500,000, with some states adding a transaction count. It also says that as of January 1, 2026, 16 states had dropped the 200-transaction threshold. A state can change its rule, so check each state's current figure before you rely on a number.

This is where sales tax nexus vs VAT matters most for planning. A VAT-style mindset asks whether you have passed one EU-wide limit. A US brand has to ask the question again for every state it sells into.

What does sales tax nexus vs VAT mean for where you place inventory?

It means the state where your stock sits becomes a state where you can owe tax collection. Avalara (opens in new tab) says merely storing inventory in a warehouse in a state can create a sufficient connection to it, and even short-term warehousing can trigger nexus. TaxJar puts it plainly: even if you are based in London or Berlin, using a US warehouse such as FBA triggers sales tax obligations in that state.

A separate Avalara guide to physical presence (opens in new tab) adds that owning or leasing a warehouse creates a presence as well. It also notes that even indirect use of a space, such as through a subsidiary or agent, can trigger nexus. For an EU brand using a third-party warehouse, that makes the 3PL's state part of your tax map.

The choice of fulfillment model changes the exposure. Shipping parcels from Europe means no US stock and no inventory-based nexus, though economic thresholds still apply. Our post on local fulfillment vs cross-border shipping from Europe compares the two models.

Each added warehouse can add a state. Our post on where to put your first US fulfillment center treats the node's state as part of the decision, and our post on when to add a second warehouse covers the extra registrations a new node can bring. Nexus also decides where you need a permit. Once you have nexus in a state, Avalara says to register for a sales tax permit with that state's tax authority.

Do marketplaces like Amazon handle the tax for you?

For the orders they process, mostly yes. TaxCloud (opens in new tab), a tax software vendor, reports that all 45 states with a statewide sales tax, plus Washington, DC, now have marketplace facilitator laws. On Amazon, Etsy, eBay, and similar platforms, the marketplace collects and remits sales tax on those orders.

Your own store is different. The same page says facilitator laws do not cover a Shopify or WooCommerce storefront, and that once you cross a state's threshold you owe tax on every storefront order into that state. It adds that in many states, marketplace sales still count toward your threshold, so a brand selling on both channels can reach a threshold sooner than its own store alone would suggest.

Inventory in an Amazon warehouse is a separate matter. TaxJar says that selling on FBA is one of the ways a seller establishes nexus in a state. Our post on Shopify vs Amazon for a US launch covers how each channel affects where your inventory lands.

Can you reclaim US sales tax the way you reclaim VAT?

No. Avalara says that US sales tax has no input tax credit mechanism. Thomson Reuters adds that a reseller can issue a tax exemption certificate and avoid paying tax on purchases of items it will resell.

That changes the cash picture, and it is one more place where sales tax nexus vs VAT thinking needs a reset. Under VAT, a business pays tax on inputs and credits it against what it collects. Under US sales tax, the tax sits at the final sale, and an exemption certificate takes the place of a credit for goods bought for resale. Ask a US tax adviser how this applies to your own purchases, since exemption rules vary by state.

How do you map your exposure when sales tax nexus vs VAT rules differ?

Work through five steps to map your sales tax nexus exposure, and keep the output in one sheet that finance can update.

Step 1: List where your US inventory will sit

Write down every state where stock could be stored: your 3PL's building, any second node, and any marketplace warehouse. Ask your 3PL and your marketplace which states hold your stock. Include temporary or overflow storage, since Avalara says even short-term warehousing can trigger nexus.

Step 2: Tally your US sales by state

Pull orders by ship-to state for your own store and for each marketplace, in dollars and in order count. Before launch, use your demand forecast by region. Keep marketplace sales in a separate column, since many states count them toward the threshold.

Step 3: Compare each state with its threshold

Look up the current economic nexus threshold for each state where you sell, using the state's own tax authority or a tax software provider. Flag states that are near the limit. Remember that dollar and transaction rules differ, and that states change them.

Step 4: Decide before you place stock

Use the sheet to test each fulfillment option, since sales tax nexus vs VAT differences mean each new node can add a state. Compare the states where a node would create nexus with the states where you already owe tax. Our post on when you need a second warehouse shows how to weigh a new node against its full cost, and tax belongs on that list.

Step 5: Register, collect, and review on a schedule

Where you have nexus, register for a permit, set up collection in your store, and plan for returns in each state. Confirm whether you need a US entity first. Our post on setting up a US entity as an EU brand and our post on getting US counsel and an accountant before launch cover who to ask. Review the sheet every quarter as sales and thresholds move.

Frequently asked questions

How is US sales tax nexus different from VAT?

VAT is applied through a common EU framework, collected at each supply chain stage, and open to input credits. US sales tax nexus is a separate test in each state, collected only at the final sale, with no input tax credit. Physical presence or sales above a state's threshold can trigger it. The sales tax nexus vs VAT gap is why a US plan needs a state-by-state map.

Does storing inventory in a US warehouse create sales tax nexus?

It can. Avalara says merely storing inventory in a state can create a sufficient connection, and even short-term warehousing can trigger nexus. TaxJar says this applies to a UK or German brand too. Ask a US tax adviser which states your warehouse would add.

If I sell on Amazon, do I still owe sales tax?

Not on orders the marketplace collects for, in the states with facilitator laws. Your own storefront orders remain your responsibility once you pass a state's threshold. Marketplace sales also still count toward the threshold in many states, and FBA inventory can create nexus where the stock sits.

Can I reclaim US sales tax like VAT?

No. Avalara says US sales tax has no input tax credit mechanism. Businesses buying goods for resale can use resale exemption certificates instead, and the rules vary by state, so confirm them with a US tax adviser.

What should you do next?

Download the EU to US Expansion Checklist (opens in new tab) and work through the Legal & Tax list, starting with the nexus item. Then read the legal and tax section of the EU to US Expansion Guide to plan your sales tax nexus vs VAT map before you place stock.

This post is general information and does not replace tax or legal advice. Thresholds, rates, and exemption rules change often and vary by state, so confirm current rules with a US tax adviser before you register, collect, or place inventory.

Share:

Related Insights

Ready to Transform Your Operations?

Get personalized insights and a custom growth roadmap from operators who've scaled hundreds of brands.

Free 30-min strategy session • No commitment required